Piggy says that the killing of Simon was an accident not murder, and that they are not to blame. To what extent do you think this is true?
Piggy claims that Simon’s death was an accident to justify his actions. Everyone participated in the killing, and they did it knowingly. Even though the killing ensued due to fear, it is certainly not an accident. There are many reasons for the murder, such as fear of the beast, being caught up in the moment and letting savagery take control of them. However, these reasons can not justify the murder.
When Ralph says, “I’m frightened. Of us,” what does he mean that frightens him?
Ralph is beginning to realize their inner evil and savagery, causing him to be frightened of his own malicious capabilities.
When they first meet up, are Sam, Eric, Ralph, and Piggy being truthful with each other? Explain.
Sam and Eric claim to not have participated in the murder and clearly aren’t being truthful with each other. Upon meeting Ralph and Piggy, Sam and Eric claim “so [we] left early because we were tired” (page 175). Their uncertainty and hesitance proves that they are being untruthful about witnessing/ participating in the murder.
What is an example of Jack’s abuse of power?
Jack abuses his power as he punishes anyone he wants. According to Robert, Jack is “going to beat Wilfred because he got angry. He later tied him for hours” (page 176). This statement proves that Jack is abusing others for no stated reason but besides the fact that he is the chief and can do what he desires.
How or why do the boys believe Simon was the beast yet are still worried about the beast’s existence?
The entire tribe, including Jack, seems to believe that Simon really was the beast, and that the beast is capable of assuming any disguise. Jack states that they must continue to guard against the beast because it is never truly dead.
When the “curtain” in Ralph’s mind is mentioned, what is suggested as happening?
The curtain is used as a metaphor. It symbolizes a difference between civilization and savagery.
In the raid, why are Piggy’s glasses taken but not the shell?
The conch no longer contains any significance or importance since democracy no longer exists. Jack doesn’t want/ need to know the opinions of his group members and hence doesn’t require the conch.
Anoushka's Blog 